Feature
Tharp�s Thoughts
Market Update for March 2008
1-2-3 Model in Red Light Mode
by Van K. Tharp, Ph.D.
I�d like to make a comment about these
monthly updates that I have been doing ever since Safe
Strategies for Financial Freedom was released in 2004.
First, these updates reflect my beliefs.
If my beliefs and your beliefs are not the same, then you
will not find them useful.
Second, I continue to do them because they
are useful for me and my trading.
And I hope they are useful to those of you who like to be
updated and appreciate the information that follows.
However, as I said above, if your beliefs are not similar to mine, then they
are probably not useful at all.
Thus, if you are inclined to do some sort of intellectual
exercise to prove one of my beliefs wrong, simply remember that
everyone can find lots of evidence to support their beliefs
and refute others. Just know that I admit that these are my beliefs and that your
beliefs might be different.
These monthly updates are published in the
first issue of Tharp�s Thoughts each month and are based on the
closing month�s data. These
updates cover each of the major models mentioned in the Safe
Strategies book: 1)
the 1-2-3 stock market model, 2) the five week status on each of the
major stock U.S. stock market indices, 3) our four star
inflation-deflation model, and 4) U.S. dollar tracking; plus one new
thing that wasn�t in the book, 5) the five strongest and weakest
areas of the overall market.
Part I:
Market Commentary
The subprime crisis continues to exert itself
on the markets worldwide and, in my opinion, we are probably
beginning to see the second downleg of the secular bear market.
This one could be very nasty.
We definitely seem to have a strong inflationary environment
and a bear market in such an environment can be nasty indeed.
Last month, I showed that with real inflation
and the decrease in the value of the dollar, you needed to make 20%
on your investments just to break even.
Gold did this and stock markets in countries like China,
India, and Brazil did much better. However,
even they are affected by the subprime crisis because when a lot of
assets are suddenly worthless, other assets need to be sold to
maintain some liquidity and, in my opinion, this is what the markets
are facing right now.
Part II: The 1-2-3 Stock Market Model Is
in RED LIGHT MODE and That�s Bad for Stocks
The 1-2-3 Model is clearly in a red light mode
and that�s not good for the stock market.
The Fed is not in the way and has actually started to lower
interest rates. That�s
positive. The market is
acting poorly and the PE ratio of the S&P 500 is above 17, both
of which are negative. Thus, we are in red light mode.
Let�s look at what the market has done over
the last five weeks and compare that with where the averages were
December 31st last year.
These data are given in the table below.
Notice that the market has now undone, in two months, all of
the gains made in 2007.

The market has also returned to more normal
volatility. I keep
getting questions from the media on what investors should do with
this high market volatility. But
my research showed that over many years the S&P 500 made weekly
changes of over 2%. Then
during the last upward phase, we had very quiet markets.
But now that the markets are moving back to normal ranges,
people are anchored by the recent past and think that these are
volatile markets.
What�s really going on?
I personally think that a lot of financial institutions are
in big trouble because of the subprime crisis and they must sell
whatever they can to get cash, and that includes many of the best
investments for this particular period of time.
When they run out of assets to sell, then things will return
to a more normal inflationary bear market scenario.
But these are huge institutions.
We may see some banks crashing before it is over, and I�m
not the first person to say that.
When we look at the strongest and weakest
areas of the markets, it seems to be mostly commodities, with even
the strongest country ETFs taking big hits.
The five strongest components, in order:
1)
Oil (86)
2)
Commodities (85)
3)
Gold (77)
4)
Taiwan
(75)
5)
Brazil
(74)
The five weakest components, in order:
1)
Hong Kong
(13)
2)
NASDAQ (16)
3)
Singapore
(20) -- this is where I
am as I�m writing this.
4)
Malaysia
(23)
5)
China
(23)
Remember when the Chinese stock market led
the list for much of last year?
Also notice that while Gold is very strong, gold stocks are
not. But I think this is
due to the liquidity problem produced by the subprime crisis.
Part III: Our Four Star
Inflation-Deflation Model
As I�ve stated many times in these monthly
updates, we are in an inflationary bear market.
The bear market is not necessarily reflected in prices, but
in PE ratios. PE ratios
will continue in a downtrend even when the Dow makes new highs.
And the inflation is obvious, but simply masked by government
statistics. Okay, so now
let�s look at the results for the last six months.
And remember that the Fed has now chosen to produce inflation
and a strong dollar devaluation over the pain of the subprime
crisis.
Date
|
CRB
|
XLB
|
Gold
|
XLF
|
Dec-05
|
347.89
|
30.28
|
513
|
31.67
|
Dec-06
|
394.89
|
34.84
|
635.5
|
36.74
|
Jul-07
|
424.52
|
39.42
|
665.5
|
32.9
|
Aug-07
|
413.49
|
39.15
|
672
|
33.75
|
Sep-07
|
447.57
|
42.11
|
743
|
34.32
|
Oct-07
|
453.26
|
43.86
|
789.5
|
33.73
|
Nov-07
|
451.26
|
41.65
|
783.5
|
31
|
Dec-07
|
476.08
|
41.7
|
833.3
|
28.9
|
Jan-08
|
503.27
|
38.62
|
923.2
|
29.14
|
Feb-08
|
565.65
|
40.87
|
971.50
|
25.83
|
We�ll
now look at the two-month and six-month changes during the last six
months to see what our readings have been.
Date
|
CRB
2
|
CRB
6
|
XLB2
|
XLB6
|
Gold2
|
Gold6
|
XLF2
|
XLF6
|
Total
Score
|
|
Higher
|
Higher
|
Lower
|
Higher
|
Higher
|
Higher
|
Lower
|
Lower
|
|
|
|
+1
|
|
+1/2
|
|
+1
|
|
+1
|
+3.5
|
The
results of this model are much more sensitive (I believe) than the
model I presented in Safe Strategies for Financial Freedom.
The model once again shows that inflation is winning
slightly. Click
here for more information on the model.
As
of this writing, Gold is now at $971 per ounce (a tremendous
increase even since last month).
In addition, the CRB is also hitting new highs.
Incidentally, the figure I�ve been using for the CRB index
is the CCI (the old CRB), which is a much more accurate
representation of the commodity market.
I have been using this index for some time.
This
is a time to be in commodities and real assets, such as precious
metals, and top quality collectables such as rare stamps, which
we�ve talked about previously in this newsletter.
If you know where to look, you may find the beginnings of
real estate bargains. Commodity
and gold stocks are probably good value plays because they are going
down as big institutions must liquidate some of their best
investments. Many gold
stocks have been down for months while gold keeps setting new highs.
And gold stocks are really leveraged gold plays since they
value gold at much less than the current price of their assets.
I�m also going to include the latest publicly
available statistics on inflation from John Williams (www.shadowstats.com).
According to Williams, inflation is running at over 11% and
M3 (another measure) is running at over 15%.
Part IV: Tracking the Dollar
With the Federal Reserve lowering interest
rates, I expect the dollar to be really weak now.
Who wants to buy treasury bills as the interest rate gets
lower and lower? So
expect currency traders to start selling the dollar and moving to
currencies that pay a better interest rate.
Look at the data in the chart because it really says it all.
Month
|
Dollar
Index
|
Jan
05
|
81.06
|
Jan
06
|
84.29
|
Jan
07
|
82.37
|
Feb
07
|
82.07
|
Mar
07
|
81.23
|
Apr
07
|
79.87
|
May
07
|
79.20
|
Jun
07
|
78.93
|
July
07
|
77.51
|
Aug
07
|
77.51
|
Sep
07
|
75.91
|
Oct
07
|
73.93
|
Nov
07
|
72.94
|
Dec
07
|
73.69
|
Jan
08
|
73.06
|
Feb
08
|
72.57
|
I�m currently on a world tour.
Last time I was in Singapore, which really likes to keep
their currency fairly even with the US dollar, a US dollar was worth
over $1.60 Singapore. Now
it�s worth less than $1.40. And
costs, especially for Americans, have gone up dramatically here.
Always remember that crisis means
opportunity. Shorting
the NASDAQ could be a good long term move, while being long gold,
commodities, and oil has been very profitable.
However, you need to always be aware of �What is the market
doing right now?� � rather than what was it doing last week.
Until next month�s update, this is Van
Tharp.
About Van
Tharp: Trading coach, and author, Dr. Van K. Tharp is widely
recognized for his best-selling book Trade Your Way to
Financial Freedom and his outstanding Peak Performance Home
Study program - a highly regarded classic that is suitable for all
levels of traders and investors. You can learn more about Van
Tharp at www.iitm.com.
|