Feature
Market Update for
March
1-2-3 Model in Red
Light Mode
by
Van K. Tharp, Ph.D.
I�d like to make a comment about these
monthly updates that I have been doing ever since Safe
Strategies for Financial Freedom was released in 2004.
First, these updates reflect my beliefs.
If my beliefs and your beliefs are not the same, then you
will not find them useful.
Second, I continue to do them because they
are useful for me and my trading.
And I hope they are useful to those of you who like to be
updated and appreciate the information that follows.
However, as I said above, if your beliefs are not similar to
mine, then they are probably not useful at all.
Thus, if you are inclined to do some sort of intellectual
exercise to prove one of my beliefs wrong, simply remember that
everyone can find lots of evidence to support their beliefs
and refute others. Just
know that I admit that these are my beliefs and that your beliefs
might be different.
These monthly updates are published in the
first issue of Tharp�s Thoughts each month and are based on the
closing month�s data. These
updates cover each of the major models mentioned in the Safe
Strategies book: 1)
the 1-2-3 stock market model, 2) the five week status on each of the
major stock U.S. stock market indices, 3) our four star
inflation-deflation model, and 4) U.S. dollar tracking; plus one new
thing that wasn�t in the book, 5) the five strongest and weakest
areas of the overall market.
I am writing
this update from 39,000 feet in the air, returning home from a six
week round the world trip. I�ve
visited Germany, Singapore, Vietnam, and Australia.
Vietnam was a trip I�ve wanted to take for some time and
I�ll be writing two articles in Tharp�s Thoughts on Vietnam.
Also, you�ll find this interesting.
It took me 23 hours from my arrival at the Sydney
International airport to arrive at JFK in
New York
, a distance of 12,000 miles. It
took another 17 hrs from my arrival at JFK to reach
Raleigh
, a mere 500 miles. Welcome
home, Van.
Part I:
Market Commentary
The subprime crisis continues to exert its ugly head in world markets.
Bear Stearns (BSC) basically had creditors who evaluated its debt at practically nothing.
As a result, J. P. Morgan was allowed to buy BSC for $2 per share with the help of the Federal Reserve.
It�s interesting that the Fed allowed J.P. Morgan to buy BSC because if you trace the ownership of the Fed back to its roots, J.P. Morgan is a big part of that ownership.
BSC was trading at $146 per share a year prior to the takeover and opened at $54.24 the day before the takeover.
And it's currently trading at over $10. Did J.P. Morgan get an absolute steal?
And how much of the price will be footed by the U.S. taxpayers?
J.P. Morgan had no time to do any due diligence. This was an immediate deal that had to get done, and it was only done because of the relationship between J.P. Morgan and the Fed.
To the credit of the Federal Reserve, without the Fed stepping in, the bankruptcy of BSC could easily have caused the credit markets worldwide to freeze the next morning. No one would have known what the exposure to BSC was. Fear would have set
in; margin calls would have been rampant and trillions of dollars in equities and commodities would have been wiped out overnight. There would have been a complete collapse of the credit markets worldwide and it would have taken some time for it to unravel.
What�s next
in this continuing unfolding drama? Many financial institutions
have had to virtually write off all of their assets involving
subprime mortgages and for many of
them that amounts to losses that are several times their book value.
They are basically at the mercy of their creditors, and their
creditors are not being kind.
The Federal
Reserve (and the central banks of countries all over the world)
are injecting massive amounts of liquidity into the system.
For example, M3 is currently rising at a 16% plus rate.
When the injections occur, the market tends to go up.
And then institutions that need cash tend to sell, and we lose all the gains. It�s
getting pretty hard to find things that are in long-term uptrends
that haven�t at least had a major correction.
Remember that
we are in a secular bear market during which PE ratios will go down
and continue to do so for some time to come.
And based upon real CPI figures (see www.shadowstats.com),
we�ve been in a recession since 2000 with the exception of one
quarter in 2003. Eight
years is a long time to be in a recession.
CNN Money
interviewed John Williams of shadowstats.com recently. To see this interview, click
here.
Part II:
The 1-2-3 Stock Market Model Is in RED LIGHT MODE and That�s Bad
for Stocks
The 1-2-3
Model is in a clear red light mode and that�s not good for the
stock market. The Fed is not in the way and has actually started to lower
interest rates. That�s
positive. The market is
acting poorly and the PE ratio of the S&P 500 is above 17, both
of which are negative. Thus, we are in red light mode.
Let�s
look at what the market has done over the last five weeks and
compare that with where the averages were December 31st
last year. These data
are given in the table below. Notice
that in two of the three markets, we are now below the 2006 close.
Weekly Changes for the Three Major Stock
Indices
|
|
Dow 30 |
S&P 500 |
NASDAQ 100 |
Date |
Close |
%
Change |
Close |
%
Change |
Close |
% Change |
Close 04 |
10,783.01 |
|
1,211.12 |
|
1,621.12 |
|
Close 05 |
10,717.50 |
-0.60% |
1,248.29 |
3.01% |
1,645.20 |
1.50% |
Close 06 |
12,463.15 |
16.29% |
1,418.30 |
13.62% |
1,756.90 |
6.79% |
Close 07 |
13,264.82 |
6.43% |
1,468.36 |
3.53% |
2,084.93 |
18.67% |
29-Feb-08 |
12,266.39 |
|
1,330.63 |
|
1,745.27 |
|
7-Mar-08 |
11,893.69 |
-3.04% |
1,293.37 |
-2.80% |
1,707.50 |
-2.16% |
14-Mar-08 |
11,951.09 |
0.48% |
1,288.14 |
-0.40% |
1,713.83 |
0.37% |
20-Mar-08 |
12,361.32 |
3.43% |
1,329.51 |
3.21% |
1,751.99 |
2.23% |
28-Mar-08 |
12,216.40 |
-1.17% |
1,315.22 |
-1.07% |
1,767.57 |
0.89% |
Year to Date
|
12,216.40 |
-8.58% |
1,315.22 |
-11.64% |
1,767.57 |
-17.95% |
I�m also
listing the strongest and weakest areas of the market in this
update. However,
I have trouble listing an area as being strong, when it is
actually down in price over the last 40 weeks.
Thus, I plan to only list the strongest areas that are also
up over the last 40 weeks. The
relative strength of each component is given in parenthesis.
Five
strongest components, in order:
1)
Spain (76)
2)
Oil (71)
Only two of
the five strongest components are up over 40 weeks.
The others, just because of recent upmoves, include
Singapore, Real Estate, and Mexico.
Even gold has had a big correction since the last update.
Five weakest
components:
1)
Brazil (24)
2)
China (25)
3)
Malaysia (26)
4)
Canada (33)
5)
UK (34)
The biggest
conclusion that we can make at this point is that it is very
difficult to find strong trends to invest in.
It�s beginning to look like it's time to be mostly cash.
Part III:
Our Four Star Inflation-Deflation Model
As I�ve
stated many times in these monthly updates, we are in an
inflationary bear market. The
bear market is not necessarily reflected in prices, but in PE
ratios. PE ratios will
continue in a downtrend even when the Dow makes new highs.
And the inflation is obvious, but simply masked by government
statistics. Okay, so now
let�s look at the results for the last six months.
And remember that the Fed has now chosen to produce inflation
and a strong dollar devaluation over the pain of the subprime
crisis.
Date
|
CRB
|
XLB
|
Gold
|
XLF
|
Dec-05
|
347.89
|
30.28
|
513
|
31.67
|
Dec-06
|
394.89
|
34.84
|
635.5
|
36.74
|
Jul-07
|
424.52
|
39.42
|
665.5
|
32.9
|
Aug-07
|
413.49
|
39.15
|
672
|
33.75
|
Sep-07
|
447.57
|
42.11
|
743
|
34.32
|
Oct-07
|
453.26
|
43.86
|
789.5
|
33.73
|
Nov-07
|
451.26
|
41.65
|
783.5
|
31
|
Dec-07
|
476.08
|
41.7
|
833.3
|
28.9
|
Jan-08
|
503.27
|
38.62
|
923.2
|
29.14
|
Feb
08
|
565.65
|
40.87
|
971.50
|
25.83
|
Mar
08
|
525.25
|
40.17
|
934.25
|
24.87
|
We�ll
now look at the two-month and six-month changes during the last six
months to see what our readings have been.
Date
|
CRB2
|
CRB6
|
XLB2
|
XLB6
|
Gold2
|
Gold6
|
XLF2
|
XLF6
|
Total
Score
|
April
08
|
Higher
|
Higher
|
Higher
|
Lower
|
Higher
|
Higher
|
Lower
|
Lower
|
|
|
|
+1
|
|
+1/2
|
|
+1
|
|
+1
|
+3.5
|
The
results of this model are much more sensitive (I believe) than the
model I presented in Safe Strategies for Financial Freedom.
The model once again shows that inflation is winning
slightly. Click
here for more information on the model.
As
of this writing, Gold is well over $900 per ounce and hit all time
highs over $1000 during the last month before a major correction.
However, these are not inflation adjusted all time highs.
The Gold market has a long way to go to reach that number,
especially if you look at real inflation and not the fake government
CPI statistics. Similarly,
the CRB has really shot up. As
a result, this is a time to be in commodities, and real assets such
as precious metals, and top quality collectables such as rare stamps,
which we�ve talked about previously in this newsletter.
There are also starting to be real estate bargains out there
if you know where to look. However,
it�s also a dangerous market, so cash is probably the best place
for most people to be.
Notice
that both gold and the CRB took significant corrections in March. However,
my suspicion is that this is temporary.
Part IV:
Tracking the Dollar
With the
Federal Reserve lowering interest rates, I expect the dollar to
really be weak now. Who
wants to buy treasury bills as the interest rate gets lower and
lower?
So expect
currency traders to start selling the dollar and moving to
currencies that pay a better interest rate.
Look at the data in the chart because it really says it
all.
Month
|
Dollar
Index
|
Jan
05
|
81.06
|
Jan
06
|
84.29
|
Jan
07
|
82.37
|
Aug
07
|
77.51
|
Sep
07
|
75.91
|
Oct
07
|
73.93
|
Nov
07
|
72.94
|
Dec
07
|
73.69
|
Jan
08
|
73.06
|
Feb
08
|
72.57
|
Mar
08
|
70.32
|
Notice how
big a drop the dollar had during the period I was on my world tour.
So far I haven�t gotten any pleasant surprises while on one
of these trips.
Until next
months update, this is Van Tharp.
About Van Tharp: Trading
coach, and author, Dr. Van K. Tharp is widely recognized for his
best-selling book Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom and his
outstanding Peak Performance Home Study program - a highly regarded
classic that is suitable for all levels of traders and investors.
You can learn more about Van Tharp at www.iitm.com.
|
Trading Tip
More
on Bailouts
by
D. R. Barton, Jr.
�It�s
tough to be a cynic � it�s so hard to keep up��
--D. R. Barton, Jr. misquoting someone from his
youth
I�ve
always had an optimistic take on things.
From
my earliest memories, I have been motivated by reward
rather than by avoiding risk.
I tend to see the positive side in people and
situations.
So
when I get pessimistic about something, all kinds of bells
and whistles go off in my subconscious.
Today
(Wednesday, April 2) as I read about how the Senate cast a
vote that was one shy of unanimous to revisit widespread
mortgage bailouts, all kinds of fireworks were exploding
in my head. We
have many �untouchable� issues coming home to roost at
once, and I�m left feeling that this could be a
significant economic tipping point.
But
before I climb all the way up on my soapbox, I want to
reiterate that I�m not a traditional �perma-bear�
who is always waiting for the economy to drive off a
cliff. Van and
I always emphasize how important beliefs are.
And my beliefs are not that the U.S. is headed to
�heck in a handbasket.�
I do
believe that the U.S. economy has remained robust through
some pretty nasty economic cycles because of our deeply
entrenched entrepreneurial spirit (supported by policies
that encourage entrepreneurial risk-taking behavior). We
innovate and produce our way out of some tough stretches.
But
new winds are blowing on Capitol Hill: one can take big
risks with greatly reduced downside.
Buy a house that is three times bigger than you can afford. Either
the real estate market will appreciate to the point that
you can refinance with impunity or the government will
bail you out.
One
of the proposals in Congress is for the Fed to backstop $400 billion worth of mortgages.
With all the huge numbers thrown around recently,
that may not seem like an eye-opening figure.
But consider that this would be more than 3% of the
nominal GDP of the U.S.
This means that every man, woman and child in the
U.S. has to work 11 calendar days just to backstop bad
mortgage decisions.
As we
keep printing money to make up for obligations like this,
the dollar will continue to weaken over time (though in
the intermediate term, it�s certainly due for a bit of an
up move to relieve the oversold condition).
Last
week, I mentioned that top thinkers out there are seeing
what�s going on as a �creeping nationalization� of
the banking system. If
the government actually starts buying up this bad debt,
we�ll have a generation of home owners who still think
real estate deals can only go in one direction.
I
don�t like the idea of folks having their houses
foreclosed. But
when it happens because of bad judgment and greed, I'm
less sympathetic. I
believe society should help those who don�t have the
means to help themselves.
But I don�t think we should have to backstop poor
decisions, even if a whole lot of people were in the boat
when the poor decisions were made.
An
interesting piece was on the front page of the Wall Street
Journal today (Wednesday) about how car loans are getting
tougher to get and rates are getting higher, despite the
Fed�s recent lowering of rates for institutions.
Talking
with banking insiders (thanks Douglas!), there is a real
fear and tightening about all loans that starts in the
housing markets and overflows into all credit sectors.
Bottom
line: the government, the scoundrels on both sides
of the aisle, will do whatever they can to make people feel
good going into the November election cycle.
So don�t expect these problems to come to full
fruition just yet. But
the credit markets really need some fiscal discipline and
some folks who made mistakes to pay for those mistakes
rather than looking for Joe and Jane Six-Pack to pony up
more tax $$$ to bail them out.
Let
the risk takers reap the rewards when they get things
right. But
let�s not bail them out when they don�t.
Next
week, I'm off the soapbox and
back to more about some cool trading tools.
Until
then�
Great
Trading!
D. R.
About
D.R. Barton: A passion for the systematic approach to the markets and lifelong love of teaching and learning have propelled D.R. Barton, Jr. to the top of the investment and trading arena.
He is a regularly featured guest
on both Report on Business TV,
and WTOP News Radio in Washington, D.C., and has been a guest
on
Bloomberg Radio. His articles have appeared on SmartMoney.com and Financial Advisor magazine.
You may contact D.R. at
�drbarton� at �iitm.com�.
Along
with systems guru Chuck LeBeau,
D.R. will be presenting the How
to Develop a Winning Trading System That Fits You Workshop in Cary, NC,
this weekend, April 4-6, 2008.
|
Melita's Inspirational Corner
The Reality Boot
by Melita Hunt
This is my last week in Australia and then I head back to my parallel life in the USA. I guess that it is fairly typical that when I am in America I look forward to coming home to Australia, and then after a stint in Australia I am ready to head back to America. I fantasize about my time in both locations and what I am going to achieve and accomplish, yet neither place is exactly as I am expecting it to be and I end up completely disillusioned until I wake up and decide to learn from the situation. The reality boot has a great way of coming out and giving me a good hard kick sometimes. Usually when I need it!
That�s why it is important to keep expectations in check.
Often, we wear our rose tinted glasses in life and always expect things to be rosy.
Of course, we get bitterly disappointed when those expectations are not met.
In reality, we would probably be a lot happier if we just let things be as they are and choose to be happy anyway.
This trip was my first time back to Australia since I was diagnosed with
cancer. When I look back now, I realize that I had set up a string of unrealistic expectations in my mind before I even got onto the plane. The sun was going to be shining
everyday. I would catch up with all of my family and friends regularly (oh happy
times�). I would have plenty of rest and
recuperation. I would handle all of my accounting and legal affairs, get back some much needed energy, get to the beach,
exercise, eat big healthy meals and still have time to do work and write as required. Family life would be smooth and harmonious (I mean who could possibly argue when there is a serious illness in the family to contend with?) and pigs would
fly�
It is a lovely a Pollyanna dream, until reality kicks in.
And it started as soon as I �de-planed� after a long haul flight. I guess that I forgot the seriousness of my illness, the jetlag that would go with it, the recovery after treatment in Mexico, the changeable weather, the impact and feelings of my family and friends and the subsequent dynamics that go with that, coming into the lives of others and their own daily dilemmas, and my overactive imagination that can fool itself into thinking I can do anything at anytime and help everyone. Recipe for disaster? You bet.
Too often we expect miracles from ourselves and those around us.
The truth is that we are all just doing the best that we can do at any given time. If we lighten up on our expectations, the world is a much easier place to live in.
We jump into the trading world, ready to make our millions, expecting the markets to do exactly what we think they should do and whammo! They do the opposite.
But the market doesn�t care; it is just doing what it does. It�s our unmet expectations about the markets that cause us grief.
We prepare for the holiday of a lifetime in Paris and imagine how perfect and romantic everything is going to be, but it rains every day. So instead of making it perfect and romantic in a different way, we just complain about the holiday that �never was� because our expectations were not met.
We jump into a relationship, imagining that our new found love is the most wonderful human being on earth. They are so kind and loving and attentive at first that we expect that they can do no wrong. And then things begin to change, and we start to blame them. We put them up on the make believe pedestal and then expect them to stay up there!
Needless to say, there have been many lessons for me on this Aussie journey. It took me a while, but I finally realized that I just had to go with the flow. It even took me a while to find the
flow because I was still pushing against everything, trying to meet some of those unrealistic expectations.
So where are you pushing? What do you expect from yourself or from others that isn�t coming to fruition or is causing problems? Perhaps it is time for you to get a kick from the reality boot.
Take a step back and either lower those expectations, or let go of them all together (even better). Just go with the flow and let it be. It may turn into a very freeing, relaxing experience. And what could be better than that?
Melita Hunt is
the CEO of the Van Tharp Institute. If you would like to
keep up with Melita�s progress regarding her recently
diagnosed lung cancer (she is a never-smoker). Please feel free to read her blog
at www.myleftlung.com.
You can contact Melita at mel@iitm.com
|