Feature
Tharp�s
Thoughts
Market
Update for the Week ending March 20th 2009
Market
Condition: Volatile Bear
by
Van K. Tharp, Ph.D.
I
always say that people do not trade the markets; they trade their
beliefs about the markets. In that same way I'd like to point out
that these updates reflect my beliefs. If my beliefs and your
beliefs are not the same, then you may not find them useful. I find
the market update information useful for my trading, so I do the
work each month and I'm happy to share that information with my
readers.
However,
if your beliefs are not similar to mine, then this information may
not be useful to you. Thus, if you are inclined to do some sort of
intellectual exercise to prove one of my beliefs wrong, simply
remember that everyone can usually find lots of evidence to support
their beliefs and refute others. Just simply know that I admit that
these are my beliefs and that your beliefs might be different.
These
monthly updates are in the first issue of Tharp�s Thoughts each
month. These updates cover 1) the market type (first mentioned
in the April 30 edition of Tharp�s Thoughts), 2) the five week
status on each of the major U.S. stock market indices, 3) our four
star inflation-deflation model plus John Williams� statistics, 4)
tracking the dollar, and 5) the five strongest and weakest areas of
the overall market.
Part I:
Market Commentary
I won�t be writing an update at the end of the
month because I�ll be on vacation and probably won�t have easy
access to email. But I
didn�t want to completely miss a month, so I�m making this
update effective March 20th, 2009.
The next update will be through April.
I get a lot of emails about the market.
Most of them are written by people who sell investment advice
(rather than education), which means you pay and they tell you what
to do. It also means
that if you are paying them, you�ll probably be unhappy if they
are not giving you advice that makes you money.
And when there isn�t too much to do that becomes a very
difficult job.
Interestingly enough, a lot of those emails are
now saying "Buy! We�re due for a rally in stocks."
However, that isn�t what our indicators are saying.
The old 1-2-3 model is still in red light mode.
And our market type model is still in volatile bear mode.
You might make money with VERY short term trading, but this
certainly isn�t the time for a long-term investment on the long
side in the stock market. Although
a few sectors (see below), might be ready for a new investment.
Part II: The Current Stock
Market Type Is Volatile Bear
The
following shows the market type, based upon 13 week rolling windows
for the last six months. Notice
that it has been a steady volatile bear.
There is even a limitation to our model in that market
changes that occurred 14 weeks ago could affect what�s happening
now. For example, during
the week of October 6th through October 10th,
the market dropped 18%. Since
the absolute value of the 13 week changes over 50 years is about
5.58%, that week alone is enough to put us in a bear market and keep
us there. However, the
market moved to volatile sideways one week before the change was due
and dropping that 18% change had no effect.
Market
Condition
|
Date
|
Volatile
Bear
|
03/20/09
|
Volatile
Bear
|
03/13/09
|
Volatile
Bear
|
03/06/09
|
Volatile
Bear
|
02/27/09
|
Volatile
Bear
|
02/21/09
|
Volatile
Sideways
|
02/13/09
|
Volatile
Sideways
|
02/06/09
|
Volatile
Bear
|
01/30/09
|
Volatile
Bear
|
01/24/09
|
Volatile
Sideways
|
01/16/09
|
Volatile
Sideways
|
01/09/09
|
Volatile
Sideways
|
01/02/09
|
Volatile
Bear
|
12/26/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
12/19/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
12/12/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
12/05/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
11/28/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
11/21/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
11/14/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
11/07/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
10/31/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
10/24/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
10/17/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
10/10/08
|
Volatile
Bear
|
10/03/08
|
Be
clear that it�s probably very dangerous to make a long term
commitment on the long side to the U.S. stock market in this
climate. I would want to
see at least two to three weeks of bull market (not volatile
sideways) to make that commitment.
In the table above, notice how often we are in a bear market.
So let�s look at what�s
happening in the three major U.S. indices.
Weekly
Changes for the Three Major Stock Indices
|
|
Dow
30
|
S&P
500
|
NASDAQ
100
|
Date
|
Close
|
%
Change
|
Close
|
%Change
|
Close
|
%
Change
|
Close
04
|
10,783.01
|
|
1,211.12
|
|
1,621.12
|
|
Close
05
|
10,717.50
|
-0.60%
|
1,248.29
|
3.07%
|
1,645.20
|
1.50%
|
Close
06
|
12,463.15
|
16.29%
|
1,418.30
|
13.62%
|
1,756.90
|
6.79%
|
Close
07
|
13,264.82
|
6.43%
|
1,468.36
|
3.53%
|
2,084.93
|
18.67%
|
Close
08
|
8776.39
|
-33.84%
|
903.25
|
-38.49%
|
1211.65
|
-41.89%
|
23-Feb-09
|
7,114.78
|
-18.93%
|
743.33
|
-17.70%
|
1,128.97
|
-6.82%
|
02-Mar-09
|
6,763.29
|
-4.94%
|
700.82
|
-5.72%
|
1,076.67
|
-4.63%
|
09-Mar-09
|
6,547.05
|
-3.20%
|
676.53
|
-3.47%
|
1,043.87
|
-3.05%
|
16-Mar-09
|
7,216.97
|
10.23%
|
753.89
|
11.43%
|
1,145.45
|
9.73%
|
20-Mar-09
|
7,278.38
|
0.85%
|
768.54
|
1.94%
|
1,187.18
|
3.64%
|
Year
to Date
|
7,278.38
|
-17.07%
|
768.54
|
-14.91%
|
1,187.18
|
-2.02%
|
Year to date the U.S. markets
are not down as much as they were in the last update, so perhaps
there is some hope for a recovery this year.
Part
III: The Strongest and
Weakest Market Components
I have a new model in which we
track the relative strength of the various ETFs representing the
economy of the entire world. I will be publishing this once a
month. Ken Long, who developed the algorithm we use, publishes
a similar report every weekend at www.TortoiseCapital.com. If
you�d like more information, then I�d suggest you attend our ETF
workshop, which is held several times each year. Ken explains
how these numbers are derived in this workshop.
The areas in green are
stronger (the total rating is at least one standard deviation above
the mean); those in yellow are the next strongest (above the mean).
Those below the mean are in brown; and those more than one
standard deviation below the mean are in red.
I�ve also taken all of the double leveraged funds out of my
database, which means that the top and bottom funds are not devoted
entirely to those groups.
By the way, if you didn�t
read my article on GLD last month, then please take a look at it.
ETFs have some additional risks that the underlying
instrument doesn�t have, just like mutual funds have risks that
the stocks they own do not have.
Namely, the instrument you are trading could fail (and cost
you extra money), while the underlying trading instrument (i.e.,
gold) could be doing fine. In
fact, I find that each month some company is closing down a set of
ETFs, and I have to eliminate them from the ETF database that
generates these charts. I
think funds are being eliminated now faster than they are added.
And what happens if an ETF that you own is taken off the
market?

Click
here to view larger chart
This world view continues to
look better with a number of areas (other than the U.S.) starting to
turn green. However,
I�ve taken out the double leveraged funds, and right now the only
reading above 60 is Russia (and that�s just because of recent
strength, not long term strength).
South Korea is at 56 and South Africa is at 57.
The next part of the chart
shows commodities, real estate, and interest rate products, along
with the top and bottom 15 ETFs.
As I said, I�ve taken out the double leveraged funds so
that we have a better example of the overall world picture.

The Strongest Areas:
1)
Russia |
2)
Copper (JJC) |
3)
Gold Mining Stocks
(GDX) |
4)
Oil (DBO, USO, and OIL) |
5)
South Africa (EZA) |
6)
South Korea (EWY) |
7)
Asia (less Japan) |
8)
Broadband |
The Weakest Areas:
1)
REITs (RWR) |
2)
Realty Majors (ICF) |
3)
Vanguard REITS (VNQ) |
4)
Real Estate 50 (FTY) |
5)
US Real Estate (IYR) |
The overall picture of what is
really weak is clear. The bottom 8 all have to do with real estate
until we get to 9 and 10, which are related to health care.
Part IV: Our Four Star
Inflation-Deflation Model
Once again, we are in credit
contraction mode, so it is not the inflationary bear market I once
thought we were going to get six or seven years ago.
But I suspect that we�ll be in one by the end of 2009.
Gold is certainly suggesting that.
Date |
CRB/CCI |
XLB |
Gold |
XLF |
05-Dec |
347.89 |
30.28 |
513 |
31.67 |
06-Dec |
394.89 |
34.84 |
635.5 |
36.74 |
07-Dec |
476.08 |
41.7 |
833.3 |
28.9 |
08-Dec |
252.06 |
22.74 |
865 |
12.52 |
08-Jun |
595.98 |
41.64 |
930.25 |
29.12 |
08-Jul |
548.86 |
39.75 |
918 |
21.63 |
08-Aug |
516.47 |
40.38 |
833 |
21.42 |
08-Sep |
452.42 |
33.4 |
884.5 |
19.89 |
08-Oct |
369.56 |
25.92 |
730.75 |
15.53 |
08-Nov |
361.74 |
23.05 |
814.5 |
12.66 |
08-Dec |
352.06 |
22.74 |
865 |
12.52 |
09-Jan |
364.5 |
21.06 |
919.5 |
9.24 |
09-Feb |
352.45 |
19.22 |
952 |
7.56 |
Mar 20 09 |
372.87 |
21.18 |
954 |
8.1 |
We�ll
now look at the two-month and six-month changes during the last six
months to see what our readings have been.
The CRB is now reaching levels not seen since 2005.
Date |
CRB2 |
CRB6 |
XLB2 |
XLB6 |
Gold2 |
Gold6 |
XLF2 |
XLF6 |
Total Score |
|
Higher |
Lower |
Higher |
Lower |
Higher |
Higher |
Lower |
Lower |
|
March |
|
-1/2 |
|
-1/2 |
|
+1 |
|
+1 |
+1 |
Last
month�s reading was +1/2, so the model is moving into inflation
again.
Gold
is continuing to show some recovery, with Gold stocks and gold coins
showing even more strength. People
all over the world are paying a pretty strong premium over spot gold
for common (not collectors items) gold coins.
Collector�s items are even stronger.
Part
V: Tracking the Dollar
The
dollar is continuing its uptrend because of deleveraging.
Month
|
Dollar
Index
|
Dec
00
|
104.65
|
Dec
01
|
109.51
|
Dec
02
|
101.48
|
Dec
03
|
86.21
|
Dec
04
|
80.10
|
Dec
05
|
85.65
|
Dec
06
|
80.89
|
Dec
07
|
73.69
|
Dec
08
|
80.69
|
|
|
Jul
08
|
70.91
|
Aug
08
|
74.09
|
Sep
08
|
75.51
|
Oct
08
|
80.39
|
Nov
08
|
82.74
|
Dec
08
|
80.69
|
Jan
09
|
81.01
|
Feb
09
|
83.11
|
Mar
20
|
85.44
|
The
dollar has been in an uptrend since July with only one minor down
month (in December). Don�t
expect this to continue for much longer (at most through the end of
the year).
Incidentally,
gold�s performance is excellent when you measure it in most other
currencies beside dollars.
General
Comments
Crisis
always implies opportunity. And
if you watch, there is plenty of it.
Right now, unless you are a very nimble trader, I�d
recommend that you stand aside in cash.
Perhaps you might want to own some physical gold, such as
coins, but pay no more than 3% over the spot price of gold for
coins. And wait
patiently for the tremendous opportunities that will occur.
There will
t be another update at the end of April.
Until the next update, this is Van Tharp.
About
Van Tharp: Trading coach, and author, Dr. Van K. Tharp is widely
recognized for his best-selling book Trade Your Way to Financial
Freedom and his outstanding Peak Performance Home Study program
- a highly regarded classic that is suitable for all levels of
traders and investors. You can learn more about Van Tharp at www.iitm.com.
|