The Little-Known Part of the Trade War That Has Cost Taxpayers 2.7x More than The Auto Bailout By D. R. Barton, Jr.


Barton TT1

Despite all the possible distractions from Hong Kong protests, votes impacting Brexit, and Aramco’s world-leading IPO, the mainstream business news is laser-focused on the trade dispute with China. President Trump’s fight with China’s President Xi Jinping continues to dominate headlines.

Even the string of all-time market highs in recent two weeks had a tough time getting any press. The pundits quickly got back to talking about tariffs and trade negotiations, as if nothing else mattered.

But there’s a directly related and very important story developing right under our noses, right in America’s heartland.

One that no one is talking about. Probably because it’s not very convenient.

Tariffs, Farms and Subsidies

Midwestern farmers are a hardy lot. They’re used to surviving everything from long hours and bad weather to periods of lower prices for their products.

But what some of President Trump’s strongest supporters are facing today is beyond anything in recent memory. This year alone has seen unseasonable freezing, drought, and now record-breaking flooding hit the Midwest.

On its own, this may have been manageable.

But it’s the little-discussed consequences of the trade war on small American farmers that has sent U.S. agriculture into crisis mode.

The numbers here speak for themselves:

44% of Iowa farmers are struggling to pay their bills.

Last year in Wisconsin, every day saw on average two dairy farms close. And the economics are even worse today.

In fact, farm incomes and credit ratings have been falling across the Midwest.

Across America, farm bankruptcies have shot up 24% to the highest rate since 2011, and total farm debt is just below its 1980 record high. That high happened just before the 1980’s farm crisis wiped out thousands of farmers.

And delinquencies are definitely rising for agricultural loans:

973 DR chart1

All in all, total farm income is almost one-third below its 2013 high.

973 DR chart2

But the real kicker is this: almost 40% of that income is some form of aid, subsidy, or insurance payment. And that’s a stat that almost no one is talking about.

But to find a way out of this mess, first, we have to take an honest look at how we got here…

Agricultural Trade

The price of agricultural commodities has been trending down for years, as farmers here in America and worldwide have been using better tools, and techniques to grow food.

Most agricultural products had their prices peak in 2011-2012.

For consumers, that’s a good thing.

But it means that farmers are on razor-thin profit margins with little to no cushion when something bad happens.

And unfortunately, the trade dispute with China has hit American farmers the hardest. America has long been a net exporter of farm goods, not an importer.

For example, in the first half of this year, China imported $5.6 billion worth of farm products from America. Meanwhile, America bought only $3.1 billion worth of Chinese farm goods in the same time period. And that’s a huge drop in U.S. exports from prior years:

973 DR chart3

So you can see the effect of the tariffs. When China responded to Trump’s tariffs flurry by putting a 25% tariff on agricultural imports from America, farmers here felt the pain. Chinese companies simply started buying products from elsewhere, especially Latin America. Brazil’s soybean inventory, for example, is set to fall to the lowest level in 20 years as China has moved to buy up farm goods there.

Those are goods that in the past would have been bought from American farmers.

Now, President Trump did go ahead and put a 10% tariff on food imports from China, but that didn’t make that much of a difference. As you saw, China’s exports to the U.S. are only about half of America’s exports to China, though that’s a much larger share than earlier in the decade.

What has helped the U.S. farmers is President Trump’s farm bailout program, instituted in May.

By some measures, it’s been very successful. As mentioned, it makes up a large chunk of the 40% of farm income that comes from the government or insurance companies.

But by the same token, that’s a mark of failure.

Proud American farmers have been reduced to relying on aid instead of being able to make a living selling their crops. And the aid isn’t covering the full impact of the trade war anyway.

Meanwhile, the cost to the taxpayer has been truly enormous. Already, the administration’s program to help farmers negatively affected by the trade war has paid out more than $28 billion.

$28 billion with a “b.”

Now I know that today, with government debt in the trillions, that may seem like a modest amount. But to give you an idea of how much this really is, think back to 2008.

That’s when the federal government bailed out two of the big three U.S. car companies: GM and Chrysler. And to be fair, Ford did receive bridge loans for their auto financing arm so they could keep making car loans to new buyers – but they didn’t have any of their company’s shares purchased.

In the years since, this auto bailout became hugely unpopular, seen by many as the government wasting money on companies that should have been allowed to go under. Others would say that it was a necessary step to keep the 2008 recession from spiraling into a depression.

After all was said and done, the U.S. Treasury reports that the auto bailout cost U.S. taxpayers $10.2 billion. That really puts into perspective what has already been spent helping American farms deal with the Chinese trade dispute – an amount that is 2.75 times bigger than the auto bailout.

And unlike buying shares in the car companies and giving loans, the farm program gives aid, not loans and equity infusions. This money is not being paid back.

In short, the American farmer is struggling – but the subsidies are allowing many to survive.

But as the President has already shown with his massive farm aid program, he is aware of this. With the 2020 presidential election approaching and farmers having voted heavily for him in the last election, chances are that he will continue to try to help farmers.

That’s why he keeps talking about China having to buy soybeans and other American farm goods as part of any trade deal.

It’s also why the Trump Administration is so urgently pursuing that deal right now.

When that deal comes, the relief to American farmers and the Midwest will be huge.

It could also benefit your wallet…

The Auto Industry Recovered – So Will Our Hearty Farmers

As you can imagine, stocks tied to American agriculture are struggling right now. For example, the Invesco DB Agriculture Fund (DBA), an exchange traded fund (ETF) that tracks the prices of corn, soybean, sugar, and other agricultural commodities, is down about 4.81% this year.

But once a trade deal between China and the U.S. is signed, you can expect this to bounce back up. President Trump has talked about China agreeing to buy $50 billion worth of farm goods from America as part of any deal.

That combined with the lifting of the 25% tariff on American farm goods sold in China would be a huge demand boost. And when demand goes up faster than supply can keep, so do prices.

Archer-Daniels-Midland Co. (ADM), a company that stores, processes, and sells farm commodities, will also benefit. It’s slightly up for the year already and has a dividend yield of just over 3%.

Once the trade deal lands, its business will boom, and the stock price should follow.

A similar story is likely for Deere & Co. (DE), the famous manufacturer of farming machinery. Deere has suffered as farmers have been delaying investment amid the agricultural slump. But all that demand still exists, suppressed as farmers make do with older equipment because they have to.

Once money starts flowing again, that pent-up demand should see Deere’s business shoot up.

Keep an eye on these agricultural plays while we wait for the trade negotiations to end.

When the Great Recession bottomed out in March of 2009, those who rode auto stocks up made big money. The same could happen with a China trade deal and a recovery of agriculture-related stocks.

I always enjoy hearing your thoughts and comments! Please send those to me using drbarton “at”

Great trading and God bless you,

D. R.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top